An Apple 7 mobile phone with a memory of 128G was sold at a price of 270,550 after the judicial auction, and the auction platform showed that the evaluated price of this mobile phone was 140 yuan, and the price of the same mobile phone of this model on Apple’s official website was 6,188 yuan. The Beijing Youth Daily reporter noted that the starting price of the mobile phone was 100 yuan, and the price increase was 50 yuan. By the end of the auction, 2,734 people had signed up and the number of onlookers exceeded 340,000. The staff of the e-commerce platform who provided technical support for this judicial auction said that the auction was a normal auction in compliance from the system point of view. Yesterday, they also paid attention to the abnormality of the auction price, and they have already fed back to the Qinhuai District People’s Court in Nanjing, which initiated the auction, but whether the auction price is abnormal is determined by the court. The staff of the Qinhuai District Court in Nanjing said that the court will investigate whether such a high auction price of this mobile phone in the judiciary is artificially malicious speculation. However, at present, there is no illegal behavior of bidders.
A second-hand Apple 7 sold for 270,000 yuan.
Yesterday, the reporter of Beiqing Daily noticed from the platform of judicial auction that an Apple 7 mobile phone with 128G memory sold for more than 270,000 yuan, and the price of the same mobile phone on Apple official website was 6,188 yuan.
The auction records on the platform show that the auction started at 10: 00 am on September 7, and the bidding period is one day. The lot is an Apple 7 mobile phone with 128G memory (unformatted, with boot lock), which was seized by the Qinhuai District People’s Court in Nanjing. Auction requires bidders to pay 20 yuan’s deposit before bidding, and then they can participate in the auction. The starting price of this mobile phone is 100 yuan, and the increase amount is 50 yuan. By the end of the auction, 2,734 people had signed up for the auction.
Although the bidding period is one day, this auction has a delayed bidding function, that is, before the end of the auction, if a bidder bids every last five minutes, it will be automatically delayed for five minutes. The reporter of Beiqing Daily learned from the e-commerce platform that provided technical support for the auction that as long as a bidder triggers the delay function within 5 minutes, the auction will cycle until no one bids within 5 minutes.
Since the first bidder bid for 100 yuan at 10: 00am on September 7th, there have been 708 bidding records on the platform by the end of the auction. After inquiring about the auction records, the reporter of Beiqing Daily found that the mobile phone bid had exceeded 10,000 yuan 11 minutes after the start of shooting; At 10: 30 on September 7, the bidding has reached 50,000 yuan, and there are still people bidding continuously. Before the auction ended at 10 o’clock on the 8 th, the price exceeded 90,000 yuan and triggered a delay. At 12: 36 on September 8, the auction ended, exceeding the original auction cycle by 156 minutes, and the delay mechanism was triggered 377 times. The bidder with the final bid number k0626 ended the auction at the price of 270,550.
The original owner of the mobile phone is the debtor.
According to the enforcement ruling provided by the Qinhuai District People’s Court in Nanjing, the owner of the Apple 7 mobile phone auctioned by the Ministry was an executor, who was sentenced by the court to repay the loan for being suspected of a private loan dispute case. According to the civil judgment of Nanjing Intermediate People’s Court, the court ordered the borrower to return 15.1 million yuan.
Because the person subjected to execution failed to fulfill the obligations specified in the effective legal documents, the borrower applied to the court for auction to seize the property under the name of the person subjected to execution. In accordance with the relevant regulations on auction and sale of property in civil execution, Qinhuai District People’s Court auctioned the property of the person subjected to execution according to law, including this second-hand iPhone7 that was hot shot. In addition, the property seized by the executor includes two mobile phones, a metal necklace, a watch, two bags and a suitcase.
In addition to this Apple 7 mobile phone with a bid price of more than 270,000 yuan, another Apple 6 mobile phone (16G memory, formatted) involved in the auction at the same time also far exceeded the previous judicial auction in terms of bidding and the number of applicants. After 995 people signed up and 51 bids, it was sold at 6,500 yuan yesterday morning.
In addition, the reporter of Beiqing Daily found that the transaction price of Apple mobile phones in judicial auctions is mostly lower than the market price, some as low as several hundred yuan, and some as high as 4,000 yuan, and the number of applicants is mostly tens to more than 100 people. This time, the latest auction of Apple 7 mobile phone in Qinhuai District Court set a record in bidding and the number of applicants.
Some people suspect that the price of 270,000 yuan is high or someone bids maliciously.
After the incident was exposed, there were doubts that the bidding for Apple mobile phones of more than 270,000 yuan may be a malicious auction. The reporter of Beiqing Daily found that according to the Civil Procedure Law and the Provisions on Several Issues Concerning the Online Judicial Auction of People’s Courts, if the investigation by the court is a malicious auction, it will be regarded as an act that hinders or resists the execution of the court. The court can investigate the relevant legal responsibilities of the buyer according to the seriousness of the case and take penalties such as fines and detention according to law.
In addition, the court may rule that the original buyer shall not participate in the bidding during the re-auction. If the buyer regrets the auction after the auction is completed, the deposit paid will not be refunded, and it will be used to pay the loss of the auction, make up the difference between the re-auction price and the original auction price, and offset the debts of the executed person in this case and the debts of the executed person related to the auction property.
According to the auction instructions published by Qinhuai court at Taobao auction, after the auction is completed, the buyer should pay the auction balance on time, pay it into the account designated by the court before 17: 00 on September 15, 2017, and sign the Confirmation of Auction Completion at the court before 17: 00 on September 22, 2017 and receive the auction receipt.
In addition, some netizens speculated based on the information such as "unformatted mobile phone with power-on lock" in the auction, whether there was important information in the unformatted mobile phone of the Ministry, and some people bid at a high price to obtain information. However, none of the above speculations have been confirmed.
The court will conduct an investigation and no illegal acts have been found yet.
The staff of the e-commerce platform who provided technical support for the judicial auction told the reporter of Beiqing Daily that the buyer’s bidding is a personal behavior, and whether the auction price is abnormal is judged by the court. "Judicial auction is very serious, the information of bidders is strictly confidential, and our platform has no right to monitor the bidding behavior of customers. This is a free bidding market in itself, and the amount of bids is decided by customers themselves." However, the staff said that it is the first time that so many people participated in the auction and the transaction price was so high. If the buyer destroys the auction, the deposit will be confiscated, and whether there will be other additional penalties will be decided by the court.
In response to this auction, the reporter of Beiqing Daily contacted the Qinhuai District Court in Nanjing. The staff said that this mobile phone was photographed at such a high price during the judicial auction. Whether it is normal trading or malicious speculation, the court will conduct an investigation. "The results of the investigation will also be unified." He said that according to the rules of judicial online auction, there was no violation of the rules in the bidding process. According to the rules, after the successful auction, the buyer’s deposit will be transferred to the court’s Alipay account. If the goods are auctioned and the balance is not paid, the buyer will not refund the deposit after the auction is destroyed, and the court can re-order the auction. At present, although the people who participated in the auction raised the price very high, they have not found any illegal activities yet.
关于作者